Site Meter Reflections on Playboy: The <i>Playboy</i> hater’s code of machismo

January 2, 2007

The Playboy hater’s code of machismo

If I date infrequently, am I a wimp? At least one of the manly men at The New York Times would say so. Thanks to Amanda Marcotte at Pandagon, I’ve discovered an NYT review of a new anthology of fiction and essays from Playboy’s first half century. Reviewer John Leland calls the magazine a plot “to create a race of men more boring and insecure than any before”:
Was there really a time when swingers imagined themselves in silk jammies chatting about Nabokov and Brubeck and the latest Cognac? No doubt. Ring-a-ding-ding. The right literary reference, the right hi-fi gear, and voilà: the freedom to go home alone, unswung, to a bit of light fiction, corny jokes and an airbrush that liberated the white-collar male from the uncomfortable burden of human curiosity.
In other words, men aren’t fully human unless they pursue intimate relationships with women. Or, at least, straight men aren’t; I would assume that Leland doesn’t put the same expectation on gay men. Admittedly, heterosexual males have had more sexual freedom than others in most times and places. But feminism has rightly told women that they don’t necessarily need husbands or boyfriends to lead complete lives, and I see no reason to deny men the equivalent option. Attributing male fascination with erotica to laziness or cowardice, as “liberal” criticism of Playboy often does, amounts to reverse puritanism, which I find every bit as despicable as the usual kind.

Posted by Brian Sorgatz at 9:48 PM

  • Blogger Salihah סליחה صالحه left this comment at January 11, 2007 7:05 AM  
    Very good points!! Thanks for stopping by my blog. Yes, it is too bad that men's balls aren't made of crystal. That sure would make things easier for me, but I guess more uncomfortable for the guys. I'm going to check out that Irshad Manji link, I hadn't seen that before! Thanks so much!
  • Blogger Brian Sorgatz left this comment at January 11, 2007 9:30 AM  
    Readers,
    Salihah refers to these two comments on her blog I left last night.
  • Post a Comment

    « Home

    Create a Link